17 November 2026
Champion House, Tromdoe, Isle of Man IM4 4RL
Isle of Man News Politics

Tynwald Preview: Hot Air or Hot Water?

This month’s Tynwald sitting promises to be a much spicier affair than the other parliamentary sittings we’ve seen since the General Election.

With plans to debate Chief Minister Chris Thomas’ Charter for Change, several motions connected to offshore wind farms and some really good questions tabled, it promises to be eventful.

The question is, will it be a case of a lot of hot air, or are some people going to find themselves in hot water?

Perhaps both.

And the good news is, it’s all going to be live streamed.

Late Homework

Let’s first of all talk about the Charter for Change, the policy blueprint that dropped six days ago, less than a week before the sitting at which Thomas wishes it to be discussed.

The first hurdle for the Chief Minister is to get members to overlook the fact he submitted his homework late.

Reports are meant to be on the Tynwald Register of Business four weeks before a sitting. This, admittedly, would have been tricky, given he’d only been chief minister for a week at that point.

That’s not a compulsory deadline, there’s just a tut-note on the order paper if you miss it.

However, he also missed the deadline (November 2) to get the report onto the scheduled order paper for this sitting – by more than a week.

So, his first task will be to get members to agree to suspend standing orders and, first, allow him to lay the report before Tynwald and then let him ask them to receive the report and note that there’ll be a finalised Charter for Change in January.

This may, in some respects, tick off concerns at the lack of opportunity for public engagement.

But it does beg the question, wouldn’t it have been easier to wait until January for the whole thing?

Or is it more about backing up campaign slogans?

Perhaps, even, more about shoring up support now, before there is any meat on the bone of the charter, to avoid dissent when the details come out?

Old political journalists, we’re a cynical bunch!

(For what it’s worth, there’s been very little talk of not letting him push ahead with a debate.)

Wind Farm Problem

The Chief Minister also faces some interesting challenges ahead of any offshore wind farm decision next month

Garff MHK Richard Henthorn has three motions that may cause Thomas to shuffle uncomfortably.

The first calls for rules to be changed so that planning applications are not considered sub judice – i.e. not for discussion – in Tynwald.

Second is a motion demanding the publication of the lease agreement for an offshore wind farm in Manx waters.

Third, there is a motion for “general debate” on the government policy for using seabed rental to achieve revenue.

Unusually for Tynwald, there is statement of opinion or specific action demand, as such, to be debated on that third item.

So they could talk for hours and conclude nothing.

But if the debate does go ahead at this sitting, you can expect plenty of dissent. The exact level of how much, however, may depend on the latest intepretation of how much anyone should say in Tynwald about a live planning application.

Appointments

There are a number of political appointments to be ratified at the sitting, covering a number of government boards, plus parliamentary appointments in terms of people to chair select committees.

The running order for events in Tynwald may depend on whether Members seek to debate the Charter for Change before the items on the original Order Paper, or to leave it until the end.

Depending on how turbulent the wind farm debates are, Thomas might be hoping to get the Charter debated first.

Question Time

Question Time promises not to be quite so tricky for Thomas.

It may be quite tricky for Home Affairs and Justice Minister Jane Poole-Wilson, as the government’s position on a number of sensitve and emotive issues is set to be challenged.

This includes the reluctance to adopt an Isle of Man version of Sarah’s Law (child sex offender disclosure scheme), an update on implementation of a domestic abuse disclosure scheme and the lack of an independent complaints procedure for the police.

If Rob Callister thought he’d ease into his role as Housing and Communities Minister, then he was mistaken. (To be fair, it’s unlikely he did think that.)

Speaker/Douglas North MHK David Ashford, who clearly relishes the freedom to pose questions in Tynwald, wants to know how Callister will exercise his ministerial functions and whether he has any statutory or delegated executive authority to do so.

Presumably this is because, while a minister, Callister does not have a department of his own.

Hopefully, there will be no surprises for Callister in the Chief Minister’s response to that question.

But the minister himself will get the chance to have his say also, as Ashford will ask him what arrangements are in place to ensure government departments implement his housing policies.

Cataract waiting lists makes another appearance in the question paper, along with the future of Ramsey Shipyard, job creation in the north, vacant properties, immigration and keeping people warm.

For the last one, certainly, more than hot air from Tynwald members is required.

You can read the Order Paper, Supplementary Order Paper and Question Paper by clicking here:

Tynwald Order Papers

Leave a Reply