Chief Minister Alf Cannan has said that while the Isle of Man’s manufacturing sector produces precision-engineered aerospace components, export controls for defence programmes are managed by the UK’s Export Control Joint Unit.
The statement came during a heated Tynwald exchange over the island’s role in manufacturing parts for F-35 fighter jets used in conflicts where war crimes have been alleged.
“We are compliant and do not export to countries where export licences are not permitted,” Mr Cannan stated.
He emphasised the sector’s economic importance, noting it employs 1,200 people and contributes to global supply chains.
Ethical Considerations
However, MHK Joney Faragher challenged the government’s stance, arguing that compliance with UK standards does not absolve the Isle of Man of ethical considerations.
“Does the Chief Minister think that involvement in manufacturing components for the F-35, used in conflicts where war crimes are alleged, raises concerns about the island being seen as complicit in those actions?” she asked.
Mr Cannan defended the sector’s strategic role, highlighting its alignment with NATO and support for Ukraine.
“The F-35 is an international programme with far greater implications than simply one conflict,” he replied.
Ms Faragher pressed further, questioning whether “legality alone answers ethical responsibility, particularly where international humanitarian law is concerned”.
The Chief Minister dismissed calls for additional ethical assessments, stating, “If she wants to stop jobs and manufacturing in the island, then that’s her business.”
He reiterated pride in the sector’s global contributions and stressed adherence to UK export controls.
Ms Faragher countered: “I’m asking further questions, and just repeating the same answers isn’t really giving me the answers I’m seeking.”
She urged the government to consider its commitment to “good international citizenship” and humanitarian law.
The exchange underscores tensions between economic priorities and ethical accountability, with Cannan firmly rejecting any shift in policy. “That’s the position the Isle of Man government adopts,” he concluded.
3 Comments