An MHK will try to force the government to introduce an Isle of Man version of Sarah’s Law.
Douglas East MHK Joney Faragher will seek a Tynwald vote that would force the Department of Justice and Home Affairs to bring forward, by next June, proposals for Child Sex Offenders Disclosure Scheme, equivalent to Sarah’s Law.
It would demand the department provides “a formal mechanism through which parents, carers and guardians may request information about a specific individual who has access to their child, where they have concerns about that individual’s potential risk” and set out clear criteria for disclosure.
That debate is scheduled for the December sitting.
It comes after Justice Minister Jane Poole-Wilson again refused to commit to introduce such a scheme. She argued there were avenues for parents to ask for information if they were concerned about a safety risk for their children, but not a specific, formal scheme as there is in England and Wales.
The department has repeatedly refused to budge on its position of having no plans to introduce a Sarah’s Law equivalent.
Faragher tried to pin down a commitment from Poole-Wilson in Tynwald yesterday (November 17).
Minister: No Plans
But Poole-Wilson said: “The department’s position remains that there are currently no plans to introduce an equivalent scheme in the island.
“This is because the current approach in the Isle of Man places greater emphasis on proactively identifying and managing known and identified risks. This includes the management of sexual and violent offenders, via Manx Public Protection Arrangements (MPPAs), prevention orders, information sharing, the constabulary’s protecting vulnerable persons safeguarding unit and multi-agency child safeguarding, involving the prison, probation service and other relevant agencies.”
She said “proactive disclosure” took place with relevant parties, where a risk was identified.
But she added: “The department recognises that disclosure is an effective part of its overall approach to effective safeguarding and we will continue to keep the position under review.”
Answer the Question!
A frustrated Faragher hit out at the minister and the department giving answers to questions that differed from the ones actually being asked.
She said: “Sarah’s Law is a disclosure scheme which enables parents and carers to make inquiries about a specific individual who has access to their child and to establish whether they have a relevant history.
“These are two separate approaches, or ways that we can provide protection for children.
“Does the minister acknowledge that they are two separate approaches, because doing my research for this question, I noticed that the department answers a slightly different question to what is asked of them each time.”
She asked Poole-Wilson to explain why her department considres the disclosure scheme “isn’t necessary on the island”.
Poole Wilson said I with the Sexual Offences and Obscene Publications Act 2021 and the sexual harm prevention orders and sexual risk orders “it doesn’t necessarily follow that people actually have to be convicted”.
She added: “There is a difference between people who are convicted and people who have access to a child who may not be convicted. But the constabulary will still manage risk on the basis of known information.
“That information, where it is available to the constabulary, and they are approached and the assessment is made, then disclosures do take place at the moment.”
System Doesn’t Cover Everyone
Faragher countered that argument.
She said: “In an Isle of Man Safeguarding Board document from April 2023, entitled Managing Individuals Who Pose a Risk of Harm to Children, it explicitly acknowledges that only a small amount of people who pose a risk of harm to children will be covered by MPPAs so actually we know from our own documentation that we are not covering most of the people who pose a harm to children.”
Rushen MHK Mark Kemp asked how many requests or informal approaches the police had received, in the last five years, about a specific person with access to child, and how many led to a disclosure.
Poole-Wilson said she did not have the data with her.
She said that the MPPA scheme was a cornerstone but there were other ways in which risks were managed.
No ‘Right’ to Information
Faragher asked: “Can a parent or carer in the Isle of Man currently make a formal request to the constabulary to establish whether a specific individual who has access to their child has a history of sexual offending and, if not, will she commit to a fresh assessment of whether the island’s existing arrangements provide the same level of protection that a disclosures scheme could offer?”
Poole-Wilson said in response: “Individuals can raise questions.
“It is important to say there is no right to information, even under Sarah’s Law in England and Wales there is no right to information. It is a question of an assessment being done and then potentially a disclosure.
“We recognise that disclosure is an effective part of the overall approach to effective safeguarding and will continue to keep the position under review.”
She said research was being carried out on the impact of disclosure schemes.
How do Your Raise Concerns Now?
Faragher’s Douglas East colleague Andy Saunders asked whether there was a “clear pathway” for parents who had concerns about an adult they thought may pose a risk to their child.
The minister said there was information about the Public Protection Arrangement scheme on her department’s website, but she would ask officers to review what was available.
There is a category in the department’s section of the gov.im website entitled: How the Isle of Man works to keep children and adults safe from sex offenders.
You can click the link here:
How the Isle of Man works to keep children and adults safe from sex offenders.
You can read the full text of Joney Faragher’s motion due to be put before Tynwald in December on the Register of Business by clicking the link below:



