21 November 2026
Champion House, Tromode, Isle of Man IM4 4RL
Isle of Man News

Taxpayers Funding Failure: Manx Radio Directors Under Spotlight

The long awaited report in to Manx Radio has finally been published by the broadcasting regulator.

It was revealed last month that the state-owned broadcaster had been found in breach of its broadcasting licence on eight out of ten days during a sample period by the Communications and Utilities Regulatory Authority (CURA).

Questions now mount over the future of its Board of Directors and the Trustees of the troubled station.

Paul Moulton who raised complaints with CURA, told Manx.News that the directors of Manx Radio should consider their positions following a damning regulatory investigation which has formally found the Island’s national broadcaster in breach of its public service broadcasting licence.

The findings raise serious questions about the competence, oversight and accountability of those entrusted with running an organisation which receives more than £1.3 million of taxpayers’ money every year to deliver a public service.

The Communications and Utilities Regulatory Authority (CURA), in its investigation and decision, determined that Radio Manx Limited had failed to comply with Condition 18(1) of its broadcasting licence.

The breach was not marginal or an isolated scheduling mistake.

CURA found that Manx Radio’s combined AM and FM speech output fell below the required 40% threshold on eight of the ten weekdays examined.

More seriously, the regulator determined that the failure was continuing, despite Manx Radio having been made aware of the concerns months earlier and having been given opportunities to put matters right.

The question now is unavoidable: how can the directors of a publicly owned and taxpayer-supported broadcaster reasonably expect to remain in office when the regulator has established that the company under their stewardship has repeatedly failed to meet a fundamental condition of its broadcasting licence?

Taxpayers Are Paying For a Public Service

Manx Radio is no ordinary commercial radio station.

It is the island’s designated national public service broadcaster, established under the Communications Act 2021, and funded substantially through an annual Treasury subvention.

For the 2024/25 financial year, the broadcaster received £1,184,024 in government funding, representing approximately half its income.

The approved subvention for 2025/26 was £1,360,705, including funding for minor capital works.

That is public money, provided to support the delivery of public service broadcasting obligations.

It is therefore entirely reasonable for taxpayers and Tynwald to demand considerably more than assurances, explanations and promises of future improvements when those obligations are not being fulfilled.

Trust

The ownership structure does not remove that accountability.

Although the shares in Radio Manx Limited were transferred to the Manx Radio Trust in April 2023, the Treasury remains the trust’s beneficiary. The company remains publicly owned.

Long Standing Failure

Perhaps the most damaging aspect of CURA’s report is the chronology as the regulator’s concerns were raised with Manx Radio following monitoring in December 2025.

A meeting took place on 21 January 2026, specifically to discuss the shortfall and possible remedies and CURA was subsequently supplied a programme analysis report in March.

Manx Radio challenged the regulator’s approach but, according to CURA, did not provide sufficiently documented alternative monitoring evidence to demonstrate compliance.

Changes were subsequently made to programming from April 20, 2026. However, CURA concluded that those changes had not meaningfully increased speech output and had failed to remedy the problem.

The formal investigation then established breaches on eight of ten weekdays. In other words, this was not a problem that suddenly appeared when the regulator published its findings. Management had been alerted, opportunities to resolve the issue were provided, and the regulator concluded that the failure continued.

Even Manx Radio’s own assessment recorded combined AM and FM speech output of just 35.75%.

CURA’s conclusion was unequivocal: the company had failed to comply with Condition 18(1).

Directors’ Responsibility

The directors of Radio Manx Limited have a responsibility to oversee the organisation, its operations, regulatory compliance and delivery of its public service obligations.

While CURA’s decision establishes a breach by the company rather than personal statutory wrongdoing by individual directors, that distinction should not become a convenient shield against questions of accountability. This is, after all, a loss-making government-owned company, propped up by the taxpayer

A board cannot reasonably claim responsibility for the successful running of an organisation when things go well, yet distance itself from serious regulatory failures when things go wrong. The board must explain what oversight was exercised, what warnings were received, what action was taken and why the problem was allowed to continue.

There should be a clear consequence as these are public appointments andm although Manx Radio is run a private limited company, they are paid by the public purse. The existing board should be required to account for this failure, and the removal or replacement of the directors should be seriously pursued by the station’s shareholder.

If those responsible for overseeing a publicly funded broadcaster cannot demonstrate that they have properly discharged their responsibilities, they should not expect to retain their positions simply because the organisation is protected by an annual government grant.

Manx Radio Gold

CURA has proposed directing Manx Radio to curtail the inclusion of Manx Radio Gold on AM during relevant hours to the extent necessary to restore the 40% speech requirement.

It proposed that the changes be completed within 28 days of implementation of the Direction. However, the regulator considered a financial penalty, shortening of the licence, suspension or revocation disproportionate at this stage. This would have been a farce anyway as Manx Radio is a government station, so it’s ridiculous to think it would be closed down because of a failure of speech percentage levels. A fine is also nonsensical as the money just goes back into Treasury – the station’s owner!

A direction to change the programme schedule does not establish whether the board has exercised proper oversight. Nor does it restore public confidence in the organisation’s leadership.

The regulator itself identified the repeated and continuing nature of the breach, the previous warnings and the failure of remedial changes as aggravating factors.

Treasury and The Manx Radio Trust Must Act

The Manx Radio Trust and Treasury cannot simply stand back and treat this as an operational disagreement between a broadcaster and its regulator.

The Trust holds the company’s shares on behalf of the Treasury, which is the beneficiary of the arrangement. That structure exists to safeguard the delivery of quality public service broadcasting for the wider Manx public. It must mean something in practice or what is the point of it?

The trustees should commission an independent examination of the board’s oversight of licence compliance, establish what directors knew and when they knew it, and determine whether those responsible retain the confidence necessary to continue in office.

Treasury should also make clear that continued public funding comes with meaningful expectations of accountability.

Future Subsidy Levels

There should be no automatic assumption that an annual subvention will simply continue regardless of performance, governance or compliance.

Tynwald, as the body approving public expenditure, should demand answers.

Manx Radio occupies a unique position in the Isle of Man. It is the national broadcaster, carries public service responsibilities and receives substantial financial support from the taxpayer.

That position brings obligations which go beyond simply attracting listeners and generating advertising revenue. The licence requires the broadcaster to provide a service that informs, educates and entertains the Island’s community, with the required level of speech output.

CURA has now determined that one of those express obligations has not been met, repeatedly and over a period during which the broadcaster was already aware of the regulator’s concerns. The answer surely cannot simply be to change the hours of Manx Radio Gold, issue a statement and carry on as before.

A publicly supported company cannot expect public confidence to survive indefinitely when regulatory obligations are repeatedly breached and the leadership responsible for overseeing the organisation faces no meaningful consequences.

The directors should be prepared to stand down. If they do not, the Manx Radio Trust and Treasury should examine the steps available to replace them.

The island deserves a national broadcaster that takes its public service obligations seriously, a board that is accountable for its performance and a funding arrangement that protects taxpayers rather than insulating management from the consequences of failure.

During the VOTE 2026 House of Keys Election, we heard time and time again about accountability. Public money demands public accountability. And accountability must mean something.

author
Juan Turner is Broadcaster, Cameraman, CAA Registered Drone Operator. Juan worked for over 10 years at ITV in regional news at Border and Granada Television and also was a regular freelancer for BBC North West. Juan is a Member of Chartered Institute of Journalists.

Leave a Reply