25 July 2026
PO Box 986 Douglas Isle of Man IM99 2TB
Isle of Man News

‘A Sin of Omission’

A woman who failed to properly declare her financial circumstance when claiming benefits has been handed a suspended sentence.

Emma Hearnden, 52, of Colby, appeared before Magistrates on Tuesday.

Hearnden had previously admitted one charge of benefit fraud through failing to declare a change in circumstances and give of making false representations to claim benefits.

The matter related to an arrangement where her ex-husband was paying the rent on her and their children’s homes.

In total she was overpaid £24,236.34 between 2019 and 2023.

The court heard Hearnden said she had failed to properly read the forms when filling them in and had always considered the rental payments a loan,

Concerning case

Her advocate Laurence Vaughan-Williams told magistrates his client was guilty of a “sin of omission rather than commission”.

He added that she is a vulnerable person with difficult circumstances.

Magistrates handed Hearnden a 20 week sentence, suspended for 18 months with supervision from probation.

5 Comments

Leave a Reply