25 July 2026
PO Box 986 Douglas Isle of Man IM99 2TB
Isle of Man News Politics

MHK’s express ‘incredulity at the errors’ in DESC report

Credit: Southern Swimming Pool

Members of the House of Keys and Commissioners have expressed incredulity at the errors in a Department of Education, Sports and Culture (DESC) report on regional pools.

The Southern Pool Board had “worked hard” to come up with a budget for 24/25 that required the same subvention as in 23/24, but DESC had concluded that there was a deficit of £220,000 which it deemed unaffordable.  

The Southern Swimming Pool presented the budget that it had submitted to DESC and told the MHKs, MLCs and Commissioners that their projected budget didn’t match the one that appeared in the DESC report which had concluded that 3 regional pools were unaffordable.  

Southern Pool

Following on from the announcement last week that the Department of Education, Sports and Culture (DESC) was planning to close the Southern Swimming Pool, a meeting was called between Southern MHKs, MLCs and representatives of all the Southern Local Authority Boards and the Southern Swimming Pool.

The meeting, Chaired by Dr Haywood MHK gathered to discuss the DESC report into the affordability of Regional Pools and the subsequent decision by DESC to propose closure of the Southern Pool. 

Commissioners shared the sense of despair and distress felt in their communities at the proposed closure. 

They were critical that the DESC plan did not attempt to evaluate the impact of the closure on school swimming lessons, after school swimming, the Southern swimming club or the many other users groups who would be affected by the closure. 

There was incredulity that the costs of closure had not been estimated as part of the proposal.

DESC

There was general anger and frustration at the lack of any solid commitment by Government to provide a replacement facility at Castle Rushen High School, despite years of promises by DESC, coupled with lack of tangible progress on the school development itself.

Speaker, Juan Watterson, presented a ‘survival plan’ for the pool, based on the subvention staying at the same level in previous years, and using data from the Pool’s budget projections. 

It was agreed by the Local Authority members that they would broadly support the survival plan and they will be taking the information back to their respective Boards. 

The ‘make do and mend’ plan is designed to keep the Pool running until a new facility, including a swimming pool is constructed as part of the redevelopment of Castle Rushen High School.

MHKs

Michelle Haywood thanked her fellow MHKs, Tim Glover, Jason Moorhouse and Jane Poole-Wilson for attending the meeting:

“It’s important that rather than just each of resolving to vote against the DESC proposal, we have something to offer as an alternative.  It’s vital that the Southern MHKs and MLCs work together to support this crucial community asset.  

“I am very grateful to the work that Juan Watterson has done to come up with a viable survival plan and show that the DESC conclusion that there was “no funding scenario where the Pool could remain operating”, simply wasn’t true. 

“I fully recognise the anxiety and distress that has been experienced by the Pool Board, the Pool staff and the whole community, which I believe was totally unnecessary. 

Michelle Haywood MHK

“The meeting makes a clear call to the Department to show a can-do attitude to supporting the Pool for the next few years until a replacement is ready to go.”

Charlie Morrey is a Broadcast & Multi Media Journalist for Manx.News and also is a Presenter on Energy FM. Charlie has previously written for Isle of Man Newspapers, magazines and also started her broadcasting career with Manx Radio.

3 Comments

Leave a Reply