19 November 2026
Champion House, Tromode, Isle of Man IM4 4RL
Isle of Man News

Can Police be Forced to Accept Independent Complaints Process?

Tynwald members will get the chance to insist on the introduction of an independent police complaints process.

The move will be made in December by Douglas East MHK Joney Faragher and follows her raising the issue with Justice Minister Jane Poole-Wilson at this month’s sitting (November 17).

She has tabled a motion stating: “That Tynwald calls upon the Council of Ministers to bring forward, within six months, the necessary legislative proposals to establish a genuinely independent system for the investigation of complaints against the Isle of Man Constabulary …”.

In addition the motion calls for a system that would:

“Ensure that all complaints concerning the conduct of serving police officers are investigated at first instance by an individual or body independent of the Isle of Man Constabulary”.

It comes after Poole-Wilson, on Tuesday, under persistent pressure from Faragher – who at one point accused her of not answering her question – confirmed that she did not believe that complaints should be investigated independently at the first instance.

On Tuesday (November 17), Faragher asked Justice Minister Jane Poole-Wilson when her department intended to establish a system “in which all complaint are investigated at the first instance by someone independent of the constabulary itself”.

Poole-Wilson said that under current legislation, the Chief Constable was responsible and that in practice it was delegated to a superintendent and the professional standards division.

“I do think that is an appropriate mechanism,” she said.

“However, I also think that the independent oversight of that whole process absolutely matters and that is where there is scope for us to, through the legislative changes that we bring forward, make sure that we have a suitably independent, proportionate and cost-effective mechanism that commands public confidence.”

She explained that when Manx police received a complaint relating to an individual officer’s conduct, it was passed to the professional standards department.

But the police complaints commissioner did not supervise all complaint investigations.

Minister: Let’s Have a Consultation

Poole-Wilson acknowledged public concerns about the process and said she planned “legislative amendments”.

But they would only come after a consultation process. That was pencilled in for the second quarter of next year, with a view to bringing forward any “required” changes after that.

However, she would not give a commitment that those legislative changes would include making the complaints process independent of the police at the start.

Faragher pointed out a similar promise about bringing forward legislation was made in 2025.

MHK: Let’s Get on With It

The Douglas East MHK added: “Calls for independence in the police complaints system have been decades in the making.

“This is not a new issue. It is really difficult to understand why this hasn’t been prioritised given the widespread support for this.”

Her Tynwald motion appeared on the Register of Business the same day as Poole-Wilson answered her questions.

If it is approved by members, it sets a tighter timescale of having to come back with proposals by June, rather than Poole-Wilson’s target of carrying out a consultation in the second quarter.

You can read the full motion on the Register of Business. Link below:
RoB

Leave a Reply