Tensions almost bubbled up at the government’s Listening to You event at Castle Rushen High School as Mark Kemp delivered a sharp critique of the administration’s record and called on ministers to resign and force by-elections.
The third of the four regional events saw a packed room with ministers facing the firing line on a range of topics.
Mr Kemp opened with a direct challenge to ministers asking: “Do you think you’ve represented us, the people, faithfully?
“Have you honoured your manifesto pledges?”
He cited a litany of concerns, including rising homelessness, deepening poverty, and struggles in the education system.
“The mental health of our kids is failing,” he stated. “The existing year sevens, and soon-to-be year sevens, are looking to be an enormous mental health burden on teachers and departments. Teachers are scared. They’re very scared.”
Finances
Mr Kemp also took aim at financial management, singling out policies such as Net Zero, the Manx Development Corporation, and immigration, which he described as contributing to “financial oblivion.”
His remarks grew more pointed as he questioned the government’s accountability: “Who’s really running this island? Who’s really calling the shots?”
When asked to conclude due to time constraints, Kemp issued a stark ultimatum: “The pillars of our community have been eroded by successive regimes, with this one doing the most damage.
“But my friends, the pillars haven’t been shattered yet. If we stand tall and united, we can create a better future for ourselves and future generations. So now I ask you this, ministers, yes or no: will you stand down as ministers and MHKs and let us call by-elections?”
Challenges
Chief Minister Alf Cannan responded by acknowledging the challenges but defended his government’s efforts. “There are huge challenges facing this government, facing society, facing us all,” he said.
“But we are seeking and putting forward the very best ways we can to tackle them—whether that’s growing the economy, addressing skills gaps, building the houses we need, or creating the healthcare system we need.”
He pointed to increased investment in mental health services and education, stating, “We’ve invested more money into children’s mental health. That’s why there is a programme of work within schools to deal with these issues.”
Despite difficulties, Mr Cannan insisted his government remained committed: “We are putting 110% in every day to try and find the solutions, not just for today but for tomorrow as well.
“Next year, you’ll absolutely have the perfect right to stand here and judge us.”
Education Minister Daphne Caine addressed concerns about schools, highlighting recent reforms. “For the first time in many years, the Isle of Man has had an independent quality assessment of our schools,” she said.
“We have identified priority areas, such as the transition from primary to secondary, behaviour for learning, and early years education.”
She acknowledged societal pressures, particularly post-COVID, but stressed ongoing efforts to improve: “We have some fantastic skills and areas of excellence. We are all on a journey of continuous improvement.”
3 Comments